| Option | Who it suits and what is included | What you do | Which island it really goes to and where it departs | Length | Rating | From | |
| Turtle Cove Catamaran Snorkel | Best for first-time snorkelers and families who want the most reviewed trip. Snorkel gear with a vest, snacks and drinks are included, with alcohol served after the in-water part. Gratuities and the ride to the dock are not | Sail a catamaran from Frenchman's Cove to Turtle Cove, snorkel with a guide, then sail back with snacks and drinks | Little Buck Island off St. Thomas, the wildlife refuge, not the St. Croix monument. Meets at the Marriott Frenchman's Cove dock with no cruise pickup, so cruise passengers take a taxi. Reviewers report turtles on most days, and one called the fish life thin | About 3 hours | ★ 4.8 (2,331) | $119 | Book |
| Frederiksted Sea Turtle Snorkel | Best for cruise passengers docked in Frederiksted who want a short, easy turtle snorkel at the lowest fare. Snorkel gear is included, and nothing else is listed. It is the shortest trip here | Wade in from the shore near the Frederiksted pier and snorkel with a guide, at your own pace | Frederiksted, St. Croix. This is a town-shore snorkel, not Buck Island. Reviewers saw turtles, rays and tarpon, one reviewer saw only a few turtles, and another says it is a short walk from the ship | 1 hour 15 minutes | ★ 4.5 (37) | $59 | Book |
| Semi-Private Buck Island Snorkel | Best for cruise passengers who want a small group and a short taxi from the ship. Snorkel gear, soda, water and alcohol are included. Lunch, towels and tips are not, and 15 to 20 percent is the customary tip | Sail from the Havensight pier to a turtle snorkel at Buck Island, then swim at Honeymoon Beach | The St. Thomas side: Buck Island plus Honeymoon Beach on Water Island, which reviewers call two islands. Meets at the Havensight Cruise Pier and leaves on time. Some days bring no turtles, and one reviewer's trip was cancelled that morning for low sign-ups | About 4 hours | ★ 4.7 (737) | $160 | Book |
| Half Day Sail and Snorkel with Turtles | Best for travelers who want a sailboat, not a motor catamaran, and a fresh-water rinse at the end. Rum drinks, beer, soda, water, snacks, gear, fees and taxes are included. Gratuities are not, and the listing quotes 20 percent | Sail under canvas to Turtle Cove, snorkel for about half an hour to an hour, then sail back | Turtle Cove at the St. Thomas Buck Island, which one reviewer calls the bird sanctuary. Leaves from Yacht Haven Grande, a short walk from the Havensight pier per a reviewer, with about an hour of sailing each way | 3 hours 30 minutes | ★ 4.8 (306) | $149 | Book |
| Buck Island Turtle Snorkel Sail | Best for families who want a long, active day. Reviewers mention slides on the boat and jumping in. Alcohol, fees, taxes, snorkel gear and a fresh-water shower are included. Lunch, gratuities and towels are not | Sail from the Westin dock to Buck Island, snorkel, then spend time at a beach, with lunch on board | The St. Thomas Buck Island, leaving from the Westin St. Thomas on Estate Bakkeroe, so cruise passengers take a taxi. Parking is $10 per vehicle at the hotel desk. Only 12 reviews, with one reviewer getting an hour of snorkeling and one turtle | 5 hours | ★ 4.2 (12) | $119 | Book |
| Live Music Sunset Sail | Best as an evening add-on for couples and small groups. Alcohol, soda and water are included. Snacks and gratuities are not | Sail at sunset on a boat with a live musician and rum punch | Frederiksted, St. Croix, from the Frederiksted Pier. A coastal sail with no snorkeling and no Buck Island. Reviewers saw dolphins, one cloudy night hid the sunset and one trip was cancelled for engine trouble | 2 hours 30 minutes | ★ 4.9 (423) | $75 | Book |
| Tall Ship Denis Sullivan Sunset Sail | Best for curious travelers of any age who like a working ship. Admission and a restroom on board are included, and the fare supports youth education programs. Alcohol and gratuities are not included | Help raise sails and take the wheel on a three-masted tall ship at sunset | St. Croix, meeting on Mt Welcome Road per the listing. A sunset sail with no snorkeling, not Buck Island. A reviewer notes limited seating for anyone who cannot stand for long | 2 hours | ★ 4.9 (46) | $70 | Book |
| Private Pirate Waters Sail | Best for history fans who want a private boat. Soda is included and private transportation is not. Check the unit on the booking page before you pay | Sail Salt River Bay with a captain who tells the history of buccaneers and shipwrecks | Salt River Bay, St. Croix, meeting at Salt River in Montpellier. A calm-bay history sail, not Buck Island. One reviewer found the bay small and the boat crowded | 2 hours | ★ 4.7 (25) | $175 | Book |
| Parasail Experience in St. Croix | Best for travelers who want a thrill, not a snorkel. A professional guide is included. Food, drinks and transport are not | Fly in a harness behind a boat, about ten minutes in the air per reviewers | Christiansted, St. Croix, from Caribbean Sea Adventures on King Street. Parasailing is prohibited inside the national monument, so this stays outside it. From the Frederiksted cruise pier, reviewers report a 30 to 40 minute taxi | 1 hour 30 minutes | ★ 4.8 (64) | $85 | Book |
| Frederiksted Sea Turtle Snorkeling Tour | Best for snorkelers who want a guided outing with a small group. Snorkel gear and a guide are included. Snacks are not. Only 8 reviews so far | Snorkel near Frederiksted with a guide, close to turtles per reviewers | Frederiksted, St. Croix, meeting at a public bathroom listed on the booking page. A shore snorkel, not Buck Island. One reviewer waited at the meeting point and nobody came, so message the operator first | 2 hours | ★ 4.5 (8) | $89 | Book |
| Taste of Twin City Food Tour | Best as a dry-land day for people who would rather eat than swim. Food tastings, lunch and a guide are included. Gratuities and port pickup are not | Walk Christiansted tasting local dishes with a guide | Christiansted, St. Croix, meeting at Singh's Fast Food on King Street. Not a boat trip and not Buck Island. Christiansted is about 30 minutes by road from the Frederiksted cruise pier | 3 hours | ★ 4.9 (317) | $155 | Book |